Platters EP Cover

"Heaven on earth, thatís what youíve made..."

The Platters


Photos                    Other Music Links               Artist Tribute Menu


The 1950ís and early Ď60ís were indeed heavenly when the Platters sang. After a few run-of-the-mill doo-wop songs on the Federal label, three of the original members left the group, and Herb Reed hooked up with manager/songwriter/producer Buck Ram, who brought in Tony Williams, David Lynch, Paul Robi and Zola Taylor. Lead singer Tony Williams had an absolutely incredible tenor voice, and the rest of the group chimed in with low key doo-wop sounds. The results proved that the Platters and Ram had "The Magic Touch."

With their first Mercury record, "Only You," the Platters reached number five; and their number one follow-up, "The Great Pretender," cemented their position as my favorite group, an honor they continue to hold many decades later.

After Tony Williams went on his own, the group flirted with the top 40 only once or twice, but continued to perform, with a changing line-up. Many groups continued to use the name, but none had any original membersóand none of them came close to the real thing. Tony had a successful solo career, though without the benefit of chart hits. He was born in 1928, and died much too young at age 64 in August, 1992.

The other members of the classic group are also now gone - David Lynch, second tenor (1929-1981); Paul Robi, baritone (1931-1989); Herbert Reed (1928-2012), bass; and Zola Taylor (1938-2007), alto.

Listening to the group over the years, I have always felt that the addition of Zola was a stroke of genius. Although her voice does not stand out in the backup vocals, there is a certain flavor added by the female sound. The few solos she had, mostly on albums, reveal her to have a slightly nasal but very pleasant voice. I think that nasal quality added to the "zing" in the vocal mix.

I also detect a softening of the doo-wop sound in their later hits, which in my opinion makes them a little less powerful than their early recordings. On the other hand, I have to declare that their rendition of "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes," strings and all, is one of the four or five greatest recordings of all time.

Although many albums of the 50ís are considered to be "one hit, plus filler," the Platters produced a number of very enjoyable albums during their heyday. Setting the tone for later efforts, they recorded a lot of standards on their first two releases. The acme of their album work was "The Flying Platters Around the World," which introduced two very beautiful Italian songs, "For the First Time (Come Prima )" and "Itís Raining Outside (Chove la Fora)."

The Platters top ten hits:* "Only You" (5), "The Great Pretender" (1), "The Magic Touch" (4), "My Prayer" (1), "Twilight Time" (1), "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes" (1), "Harbor Lights" (8).

Warning: Beware of low-budget "greatest hits" compilations. There are some available that are not by the original group, even though the original members are shown on the cover and there is nothing to warn you of this on the package.

In 2012, after a half-century of litigation, a federal court ruled that original member Herbert Reed had sole rights to use of the name. The dozens of fake groups were put in their place, and Reed's company continues to control the only legal right to The Platters. Read about it here.

--Dick Estel, updated August 2006, November 2013 and August 2021

*Billboard pop singles chart, as reported in the book Top 40 Hits, copyright 1992 by Joel Whitburn.


Click on the photo for a larger image. Photos open in a new window.

Great Pretender 45
Their earliest album cover That's lead singer Tony Williams standing at center The Magic Touch CD Cover Around the World Album Cover
Platters History of Rock & Roll Official Web Site Rock & Roll Hall of Fame
The Platters on You Tube Platters Biography Platters Profile
Platters Information Site Platters Wikipedia Article Platters Music on Amazon
Buddy Holly Elvis Presley Fats Domino Everly Brothers Chuck Berry Little Richard



Mini Guitar

Artist Tributes

Mini Guitar

Music Links

Mini Guitar

Bluegrass Links

Mini Guitar

Off the Wall Songs

Mini Guitar

Estel Home Page

Mini Guitar

Top 100 Records

Mini Guitar

Jukebox Memories

Mini Guitar

Top 100 Comments

Mini Guitar

Music Club

Mini Guitar


Mini Guitar

Music at Amazon

Mini Guitar

Recommended Links


Updated August 13, 2021